Showing posts with label theology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label theology. Show all posts

Friday, August 21, 2015

What I learned in the wilderness with my family.

July 2015, my wife and I took our children into the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness.  We chose a plan that included a base-camp on Seagull Lake.  It was an amazing trip, and easier than many suppose.  We had great support from other people, and of course God working through other people to ensure that it was a great experience.  Monday was our travel day.  We drove from our home in Appleton Wisconsin to Duluth, then along the north shore of Lake Superior to Grand Marais, and then along the Gunflint trail to Tuscarora Lodge, on the edge of the Wilderness.  Tuesday was an adventure canoeing to a campsite.  Wednesday was spent land locked due to high winds, Thursday was spent exploring the Western end of the lake, and Friday was a disorienting trip out of the Wilderness. 

Part 1 of 4: God provides a safe place, and St. Raphael intercedes for us. 

Monday night, we had an orientation at Tuscarora with our outfitter.  We reviewed the map and got some suggestions for campsites.  We learned about the Wilderness, and the special rules for leaving no trace, and made sure that we had all the proper licenses and permits.  That night, we settled into the bunk house, but some members of our party were too excited to sleep.  It was a rare hot night in the north woods, so we all slept on top of our sleeping bags.  The mosquitos were particularly bad since it was a still night. 

On Tuesday morning we had a great breakfast of French toast, fruit, and hard-boiled egg canoes and coffee.  After the restless night, the coffee was very welcome.  A stiff breeze helped to cool us a little, and keep the mosquitos away.  Each of us used a flush toilet, something that we assumed we would miss the next few days.  Dan from Tuscarora Lodge took us out to the public launch, showed us a few tricks for lifting the 20 ft., 50 lb. canoe, and then helped us load and launch it. 

We started out across the open section of the eastern part of Seagull lake.  The wind had picked up a bit and there were a few waves as we went out across the water.  It took some trust in God, knowing that we were frequently in areas where the water was very deep.  Sharp drop-offs and sheer cliffs are normal for this lake, and very quickly we were far from shore.  We prayed for safety and continued to the north end of Fish Hook Island.  After that we stayed along the shore.  Even close to shore, there were few people around and the water was deep. 

The wind continued to pick up.  Every inlet, point, and island looked the same, and it was frequently difficult to judge distances.  My wife wanted to stay close to shore, which was probably the best idea (more on that when we get to day 4).  I was reluctant to do that at first, but soon saw the benefits.  We went into one calm bay where a loon sang to us.  We were right up against the sheer cliffs of the palisades on the north side of the lake.  I settled into a deep appreciation, not only for God’s creation, but also: our health, that allowed us to take this kind of trip, the foresight of people who preserved wilderness areas so that all people can enjoy them, and for our children, and especially for my wife who first suggested that we take the children on this adventure. 

As the wind picked up, and we headed directly into it, we began looking for the campsites that our outfitter had recommended.  The first was in a scenic area where there was good hiking and a great view.  It was taken.  The second was across a bay from that one, with a nice beach landing, a great place for the children to swim.  Taken.  So we continued on, into the wind.  As the waves got a little bigger and the clouds a little darker, my wife said that maybe we should pray for a safe passage.  She wondered out loud, who might be the patron saint of travelers.  “St. Raphael,” was the response from our 9-year-old.  So we asked the archangel to pray for us as we continued our search for a place to spend the next 3 days and nights.  After seeing the first recommended sites taken, I prayed quietly to myself, that if the next campsite was right for us, that it would be open.  I had to trust God that maybe the ones that were taken were not right for us, or that God had something more appropriate for our family.  Storms were predicted, and we wanted to set up camp before it was too late. 

As we rounded a point between an island and the shore, we saw a quiet bay with a loon.  Was this a campsite? Was it open?  The map showed that site on the other side of a peninsula.  If there was a landing there, it was probably the site.  We went around the peninsula, and the wind and waves were a little intimidating.  It pushed us toward the rocks.  We landed next to a large rock, and Maureen and the children went to look for the campsite.  There was a fire grate, tent pad, and trail to a “wilderness box” latrine.  It was a campsite, and it was open.  We unloaded our canoe, and claimed our site.  It was amazing!  We thanked God (and St. Raphael for his prayers) for getting us there safely, and to such a beautiful place. 


God was not done blessing us on our first trip into the wilderness.  The storm that was threatening, broke up and blew around us.  The wind, which became stronger, kept the mosquitos away.  And we found a level, rock-and-root-free area to set up our 7 person tent.  As we set up our tent , fly, hammock and cook stove, we kept encountering ways that God had blessed us.  Two trees were perfect distance from each other for the hammock, set in a small clearing away from the main camp.  A tall tree was 100 feet from camp that had not been touched by fire, perfect for hanging our garbage.  Two more trees were close enough, with nothing between them for our dining fly and food prep area.  Everything came together to make a perfect home away from home. 

That night, as we settled into our tent and sleeping bags, we were grateful for one more thing, a well- designed tent.  The tent had come from relatives who had used it 2-3 times, and then passed it on to us.  It was very wind resistant.  Something that we did not know until it was buffeted by 30-40 mph winds that night.  Never before had I staked down the rain fly on this tent.  It flapped loudly all night, something that we had never experienced in that tent.  The tent withstood the wind, despite the fact that the soil was so thing that many of the stakes were barely in the ground.  Boundary Waters Canoe area wilderness had very thin soil on top of bedrock.  Later someone commented that our site was sheltered from the wind, which meant that the wind was stronger than we felt.  Yet another way that God had provided a safe place for us. 



Each night, most of us rest in comfortable beds, sheltered in sturdy houses.  God provides us with the shelter.  He may have worked through the craftspeople who built it, and our employers who pay our wages.  But all of these are ways that God is working through others and through us to give us the shelter that we need.  We received direction and support from many people for our Boundary Waters adventure.  When we allowed God to work through others, and trusted in what he had prepared for us, we were richly rewarded.  

Thursday, July 23, 2015

Something Fishy in John 6

The sixth chapter of the Gospel according to John is the key to understanding the Eucharist.  We get to hear this good news proclaimed in the next 5 Sundays, July 26 – August 23, the .  It is filled with rich symbols of the Eucharist and should be required reading for every Christian.  It explains, clearly and in detail that Jesus gives us himself in the Eucharist to feed us spiritually and save us from death. 
This Sunday we get John 6:1-15, the feeding of the 5000.  This is one of the few events that is told in all four Gospel accounts.     
  • The crowds have followed Jesus and the disciples to a deserted place. 
  • They are unable to feed themselves.  
  • Jesus feeds over 5,000 people with 5 loaves and 2 fish. 

John adds some important details that are really exciting: 
  • The location, the Sea of Galilee is mentioned by name.  
  • Passover is coming soon.  
  • The account in the Gospel according to John is arranged within the “Bread of Life discourse” (Chapter 6).

Here are just some of the amazing, deeper meanings found in these 15 verses. 

6:1 – the Sea of Galilee is where the risen Jesus appears to Peter, and six other disciples (John 21:1-25).  John the Evangelist mentions the Sea of Galilee to ensure that we do not miss the connection with the resurrection. 

6:4 – the Passover was near.  
  • The Passover meal had symbols and details that spoke volumes to Jewish people then and now. The Passover as a historical event celebrated God rescuing the Israelites from slavery in Egypt. 
  •  Bread, which always was an important part of the ritual eventually took the place of the lamb when the Jewish people were not able to have the lamb sacrificed at the Temple. 
  • It was expected that the Messiah would come during the Passover. 
  • Some 20th century scholars have proposed that the expectation of the Messiah and the importance of the bread came together with the bread being a symbol of the Messiah. 

6:6 – Jesus puts a test to the disciples.  John says that Jesus asked the disciples where they would get food for all these people as a test.  The challenge from Jesus’s perspective is not how to feed the people physically, but how to increase the faith of the disciples and the people. 

6:9 – 5 barley loaves – barley was the first grain harvested, so these loaves were the first fruits of the harvest.  Barley is also the typical food of the poor.  In the first reading this Sunday we read about how Elisha, one of the greatest prophets multiplied 20 barley loaves to feed 100 people.  (2Kings 4:42-44).  Jesus shows that he is greater than Elisha and the prophets. 

6:9 – 2 fish – If you have seen the Christian fish symbol, you may be aware that the Greek word for fish, Ichthus is written with 5 letters, Iota, chi, theta, upsilon, sigma, which are the first letters of the words Jesus, Christ,
God(‘s), Son, Savior.  The fact that this replaces lamb should not be lost on Christians.  Jesus Christ, the Son of God, our Savior takes the place of the lamb at this new Passover. 

6:11 – John tells us that Jesus gave thanks, or in Greek, “eucharistein.”  John uses this word in case we missed the other symbols. 

6:11 – they had as much as they wanted.  John tells us that Jesus was able to fulfill the needs of all those gathered together. 

6:13 – they filled 12 baskets with what was left.  12 is a symbolic number, for the 12 tribes of Israel, the 12 disciples, and indicates that all of Israel, or all the believers would receive the spiritual food. 

6:14 – the crowd acknowledges that Jesus is the prophet who has come into the world.  The miracle and symbols of the loaves and fish have convinced people that Jesus is the Messiah. 

6:15 – the crowd misunderstands Jesus’s mission.  They want to make him an earthly king.  They want to be saved from the oppression of the Romans, as their ancestors were saved from slavery to the Egyptians. 


A question for us, as we receive the Eucharist, do contemplate the deeper meaning and allow ourselves to be spiritually fed?  Can we, unlike many in the crowd, go beyond our immediate needs to appreciate the gift of salvation.  

Friday, July 17, 2015

Shepherds Wanted

Jeremiah 23:1-6;  When the Israelites were ruled by selfish kings who ignored the cry of the poor, God himself promised to lead them home, and to give them shepherds who would care for them with wisdom, justice, and righteousness.  In our contemporary world, we may see some of the same problems that the people of Jeremiah’s time witnessed.  From our 21st century Christian perspective, the promise is fulfilled in Jesus and his Apostles.   Yet we still witness some of the same issues that Jeremiah did. 

In chapter 22 of Jeremiah, he lists the faults of the kings of his time: oppressing foreigners, widows, and orphans.  They did not pay just wages, and failed to bring justice to the weak and the poor.  They shed the blood of the innocent.  He attributes their punishment, death and exile at the hands of the Babylonians to their injustice. 

In the 21st century, how much of this is still going on?  The immigrant is vilified, and the political candidate who does so rises in the polls.  The poor, particularly single mothers and their children, contemporary widows and orphans, receive no support.  Large corporations run by billionaires pay wages that are below the poverty line, and assign employees to fewer hours so that they are not eligible for health care benefits.  Racism is rearing its ugly face as we try to unwind centuries of slavery followed by systematic discrimination.  The blood of the innocents is shed in abortion, war, terrorism, and poverty related illnesses.

Now as much as then, we need secular and religious shepherds who will lead with wisdom, justice, and righteousness. 

Friday, June 26, 2015

Should “Immoral” = “Illegal?”

If something is immoral, do we have to make it illegal? 

How do we discern which moral norms to make into laws? 

Whose morality do we follow? 

On the surface it seems that laws and morality serve the same purpose.  Both appear to restrict certain activities that might hurt other people or damage the common good.  But morals are different than laws.  Moral norms are meant to make us the best that we can be.  The Ten Commandments were the rules of a freed people (Israelites freed from slavery in Egypt) who God chose to be his people.  It is more like a marriage covenant where we choose to live a certain way in order to be in a relationship with another person.  In marriage the spouses live a certain way that allows them to grow closer to each other.  In the Ten Commandments the people live a certain way to grow closer to God.  If a person must decide if an action is moral, they can consider a guiding principal, a moral norm.  Jesus gave us the great commandment, love God, and love your neighbor.  It is a reminder that morals do not restrict behavior, but open the person up to being in a relationship with God. 

Laws exist to help people live together in a community.  We agree to follow these rules that this community has agreed to live by.  One may not agree with all of the laws, but we accept them in order for our communities, states, and countries to work smoothly.  If there is no law against something, it is generally permitted.  Laws tell us what we cannot, do.  Morals tell us what we should do. 

Many times laws and morals are the same.  Killing an innocent person is, or ought to be, against the law.  Lying about an investment opportunity in order to sell it at a higher price is, or ought to be, against the law.  These actions are immoral, and illegal.  They are immoral independent of the law.  Even if it were legal to kill an innocent person, it would still be seriously immoral.  Even if there are no regulations about misrepresenting an investment, it is still immoral to take money from people and to lie. They are also actions that are generally illegal.  Our society does not allow them because it disrupts our community.  

Sometimes the law allows certain activities that many consider immoral.  It is legal to say or publish untrue things about people.  A person might be sued and have to pay monetary damages, but there would be no imprisonment or banishment from society.  Political action committees can spread all kinds of falsehood about a candidate immediately before an election, and suffer little or no penalties.  Despite the commandment, “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor,” a person in our country can say these things because of our right to free speech.  It is not against the law for a 55 year old married man to have an extra-marital relationship with a 19 year old.  It is certainly not moral under most systems of morality.  Not everything that is legal is moral. 

Where do we draw the line?  What should be the indicator that something should be illegal? 

We could make things illegal if they harm other people.  We currently do not make things illegal that cause emotional harm.  Take the case of the above mentioned 55-year-old.  He is harming his spouse certainly.  But he is also harming his children, and probably is causing emotional harm to the much younger woman.  We may be disgusted by his actions.  We may decide to never associate with him again.  He might lose much of his material possessions in a civil suit for “loss of affection.”  But despite the great harm to many people, he suffers no criminal penalties.  If he caused physical harm to his spouse, children, or mistress, he would probably be arrested for domestic violence.  But since he is causing

emotional harm, there is no criminal penalty. 

Perhaps we should make it illegal for him to remarry after he divorces his first spouse.  Obviously he has caused emotional harm to the children, and his spouse.  It would probably be in the best interest of society if that person did not get remarried.  Since his actions cause emotional harm to others, maybe we should revoke is right to marry. 

Some suggest that law teaches people about morality.  If something is legal, then people will think that it is moral; if it is illegal, people will think that it is immoral.  On the surface that seems logical.  But there are many instances in our society where people acknowledge that something is legal, yet still consider it immoral.  None of the seven deadly sins is illegal in itself: lust, greed, envy, pride, sloth, gluttony, and wrath.  Only certain ways of acting on those sins is illegal.  Wrath is not illegal until it turns to assault.  Greed and envy are not illegal until they become theft.  Pride, sloth, gluttony and lust, and most of the actions that are motivated by them are not illegal.  Even though they are legal, we still acknowledge that they are immoral. 
Unless we want to make all immoral actions illegal, we have to make distinctions.  It would seem that in our country we make laws about actions that harm another person physically, affect their property, or affect their basic rights as outlined in our constitution. 

Whose morality do we follow? 

There are many different moral systems.  They often come to the same conclusions and the same general behavior norms.  But, frequently in our moral systems disagree in important areas.  An example: “Is it ever permissible to directly, and intentionally kill an innocent human being?”

From the perspective of a Catholic moral system the answer is, “not ever.” 

From a different moral system that emphasizes the greatest good over individual events the answer might be, “If it saves other lives, it may be permissible.”

Not all moral systems come to the same conclusions in every case.  In our pluralistic society, where we do not all have the same moral convictions, when do we use civil law, and when do we use moral persuasion?  It would seem prudent to use civil law sparingly so as not to interfere with individual or collective rights. 

I would suggest three categories where laws would be more appropriate than moral persuasion: 
  • To protect the innocent from harm or grave injustice, especially threats to life, health, and basic human rights. 
  • To correct an injustice and to restore rights when they have been denied. 
  • To allow all people to participate in our society, and to promote the common good. 


I am curious about what others think, When should we make our morality the law?